No edit summary |
|||
(4 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown) | |||
Line 213: | Line 213: | ||
#Y'know what, maybe I am bias towards Big Nipper but at the same time I'm joining Nick here. As pointed out in Series 10, Carbide made impact to Big Nipper and caused no damage. I find it a shame Big Nipper was KO'd early on by Gabriel because I think it may have given Carbide some trouble. For starters the flywheel could have caused some lifts upon impacting Carbide, which in turn would have caused the bar to hit the arena floor, potentially stopping it briefly which then could allow for a split second hit from Big Nipper to hit the chain. Obviously, that requires luck but what doesn't is Big Nipper's durability and aggression which can occour by it running around Carbide to hit the sides or back end. There's also that scoop which does exist (although I am hesitant to use this as a reason) For me its a battle of avoiding the bar and going in when it's safe.[[User:Diotoir the son of nemesis|<font color="red">Diotoir</font><font color="black"> the</font><font color="red"> son</font><font color="black"> of</font><font color="red"> nemesis</font>]] ([[User talk:Diotoir the son of nemesis|talk]]) 06:50, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
#Y'know what, maybe I am bias towards Big Nipper but at the same time I'm joining Nick here. As pointed out in Series 10, Carbide made impact to Big Nipper and caused no damage. I find it a shame Big Nipper was KO'd early on by Gabriel because I think it may have given Carbide some trouble. For starters the flywheel could have caused some lifts upon impacting Carbide, which in turn would have caused the bar to hit the arena floor, potentially stopping it briefly which then could allow for a split second hit from Big Nipper to hit the chain. Obviously, that requires luck but what doesn't is Big Nipper's durability and aggression which can occour by it running around Carbide to hit the sides or back end. There's also that scoop which does exist (although I am hesitant to use this as a reason) For me its a battle of avoiding the bar and going in when it's safe.[[User:Diotoir the son of nemesis|<font color="red">Diotoir</font><font color="black"> the</font><font color="red"> son</font><font color="black"> of</font><font color="red"> nemesis</font>]] ([[User talk:Diotoir the son of nemesis|talk]]) 06:50, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
||
#Yeah, I'll back this side as well. If Big Nipper can bare the brunt of early Carbide hits, I can see it giving them some trouble. It's important to remember Carbide didn't get the attack on Big Nipper that disabled part of its drive - that was Gabriel's doing. Big Nipper with the claw configuration did well to get underneath robots like Apollo and overturn them using the weapon, so they're more than controlled enough to give Carbide some real problems here throughout the fight. This combined with Nick's points regarding their resilient armour, is enough to give them my vote. [[User:SFCJack|SFCJack]] ([[User talk:SFCJack|talk]]) 10:32, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
#Yeah, I'll back this side as well. If Big Nipper can bare the brunt of early Carbide hits, I can see it giving them some trouble. It's important to remember Carbide didn't get the attack on Big Nipper that disabled part of its drive - that was Gabriel's doing. Big Nipper with the claw configuration did well to get underneath robots like Apollo and overturn them using the weapon, so they're more than controlled enough to give Carbide some real problems here throughout the fight. This combined with Nick's points regarding their resilient armour, is enough to give them my vote. [[User:SFCJack|SFCJack]] ([[User talk:SFCJack|talk]]) 10:32, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
||
+ | #Honourable vote for Big Nipper, since the three votes above have swayed me onto the side of the underdog. [[User:SpaceManiac888|<span style="color:#B7410E">SpaceManiac888</span>]] [[User Talk:SpaceManiac888|<span style="color:#228B22">(Talk)</span>]] 23:13, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
||
|<!-- If you think Carbide won, sign your name under here -->'''Votes for Carbide''' |
|<!-- If you think Carbide won, sign your name under here -->'''Votes for Carbide''' |
||
#Big Nipper is unlucky to face Carbide here as I can see it winning against the other two robots here. It would be better to use the claws and try to get under Carbide, lift it and force the spinner into the floor and try to push away from there, but that just won't happen for the full 3 minutes. Big Nipper just doesn't have the wedgey shape required to resist the spinner, and will eventually be shredded. [[User:Jimlaad43|<font color="black">J</font><font color="gold">im<font color="black">laa</font><font color="gold">d4</font></font><font color="black">3</font>]]([[User talk:Jimlaad43|talk]]) 23:10, January 27, 2020 (UTC) |
#Big Nipper is unlucky to face Carbide here as I can see it winning against the other two robots here. It would be better to use the claws and try to get under Carbide, lift it and force the spinner into the floor and try to push away from there, but that just won't happen for the full 3 minutes. Big Nipper just doesn't have the wedgey shape required to resist the spinner, and will eventually be shredded. [[User:Jimlaad43|<font color="black">J</font><font color="gold">im<font color="black">laa</font><font color="gold">d4</font></font><font color="black">3</font>]]([[User talk:Jimlaad43|talk]]) 23:10, January 27, 2020 (UTC) |
||
Line 222: | Line 223: | ||
#Carbide can attack Big Nipper and keep the pressure on throughout the fight to win on a full judges decision. <span style="font-family: Courier">[[User:Adster1005|<font color="#191970">Adster</font>]][[User talk:Adster1005|<font color="#FF0000">1005</font>]]</span> 08:06, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
#Carbide can attack Big Nipper and keep the pressure on throughout the fight to win on a full judges decision. <span style="font-family: Courier">[[User:Adster1005|<font color="#191970">Adster</font>]][[User talk:Adster1005|<font color="#FF0000">1005</font>]]</span> 08:06, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
||
#I definitely think Big Nipper has a better shot than Magnetar, and threatens to win this match. If it could enter the fight with its lifting wedge then all of a sudden I reckon there would be a slight Big Nipper majority, but unfortunately that luxury is afforded only to the Track-tion team. I also think the claws setup stands a good chance of beating Carbide, as it would be able to slip under the bar and allow the titanium brick to complete some pushes, but it wouldn't be able to complete a lift due to the risk of Carbide's bar falling on top of the robot or hitting the claws. It would essentially be a flat wedge, which might be enough, but I'm not confident enough to back it. Here's my concerns. Big Nipper stood up beautifully to the one hit it took from Carbide in reality, taking essentially no damage at all, but I'm conscious of Carbide's condition at that point in time. After a full three-minute slug with Gabriel which later forced intensive parts repairs that nearly put Carbide out of the competition, Carbide was likely running its bar at a reduced speed to preserve enough battery to survive the match, without also disabling the bar completely as if to say 'my weapon's dead'. This hit was also directly on the side of Big Nipper, whereas Carbide would normally aim for what is going to be Big Nipper's largest weakness here, its flat corners. Although the armour of Big Nipper is extremely strong, it's still a 110kg robot at the end of the day, and any big hit from Carbide will send it spinning away upon connection with the flat corners. The damage may be lower than usual, but Big Nipper won't be causing any, and its own control is somewhat limited by Carbide's blows. My final concern is... what if the team did put the spinner on? We take it for granted that Big Nipper will use its defensive weapons, but when they fought Carbide in Series 10, they did not. Their intention to use the wedge at first shows that they were trying to counter Carbide rather than Gabriel, and for whatever reason, they seemed to think the vertical disc was a wiser choice than the claws. I definitely considered a Big Nipper win by wedging Carbide around the arena, or even trying to pinch the weapon shaft, but I can't quite do it. Congratulations Carbide. <span style="font-family:Pirulen; font-size:10pt">[[User:ToastUltimatum|<font color="maroon">'''T'''</font><font color="ff8c00">'''OAS'''</font>]][[User talk:ToastUltimatum|<font color="maroon">'''T'''</font>]]</span> 10:07, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
#I definitely think Big Nipper has a better shot than Magnetar, and threatens to win this match. If it could enter the fight with its lifting wedge then all of a sudden I reckon there would be a slight Big Nipper majority, but unfortunately that luxury is afforded only to the Track-tion team. I also think the claws setup stands a good chance of beating Carbide, as it would be able to slip under the bar and allow the titanium brick to complete some pushes, but it wouldn't be able to complete a lift due to the risk of Carbide's bar falling on top of the robot or hitting the claws. It would essentially be a flat wedge, which might be enough, but I'm not confident enough to back it. Here's my concerns. Big Nipper stood up beautifully to the one hit it took from Carbide in reality, taking essentially no damage at all, but I'm conscious of Carbide's condition at that point in time. After a full three-minute slug with Gabriel which later forced intensive parts repairs that nearly put Carbide out of the competition, Carbide was likely running its bar at a reduced speed to preserve enough battery to survive the match, without also disabling the bar completely as if to say 'my weapon's dead'. This hit was also directly on the side of Big Nipper, whereas Carbide would normally aim for what is going to be Big Nipper's largest weakness here, its flat corners. Although the armour of Big Nipper is extremely strong, it's still a 110kg robot at the end of the day, and any big hit from Carbide will send it spinning away upon connection with the flat corners. The damage may be lower than usual, but Big Nipper won't be causing any, and its own control is somewhat limited by Carbide's blows. My final concern is... what if the team did put the spinner on? We take it for granted that Big Nipper will use its defensive weapons, but when they fought Carbide in Series 10, they did not. Their intention to use the wedge at first shows that they were trying to counter Carbide rather than Gabriel, and for whatever reason, they seemed to think the vertical disc was a wiser choice than the claws. I definitely considered a Big Nipper win by wedging Carbide around the arena, or even trying to pinch the weapon shaft, but I can't quite do it. Congratulations Carbide. <span style="font-family:Pirulen; font-size:10pt">[[User:ToastUltimatum|<font color="maroon">'''T'''</font><font color="ff8c00">'''OAS'''</font>]][[User talk:ToastUltimatum|<font color="maroon">'''T'''</font>]]</span> 10:07, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
||
+ | #Remember when Big Nipper fought Supernova in its Series 8 Group Battle? Sustained collisions with the latter's flywheel caused its own disc arm to bend and be temporarily put out of commission for the Head-to-Head stage. Even if the opportunity to damage Carbide's more vulnerable sides and wedge is tempting, any collisions with the bar will only leave that arm in a similarly-twisted state. With that in mind, I can see Team Titanium being better off using the claws, but even then they're more liable to getting broken if they so much as clip the bar. Like others, I'm genuinely mystified as to why Big Nipper's scoop weapon caused issues with the producers and not Track-tion's loaned wedge; the scoop would've probably made for a more even contest had it not been outlawed. However, as we are only considering Big Nipper's TV armament, I regret to say that there's very little it can do to stop the Carbide crusade at this point. [[User:VulcansHowl|<font color="green">'''Vulcans'''</font>]][[User talk:VulcansHowl|<font color="#5d8aa8">'''Howl'''</font>]] 11:18, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
||
− | |||
+ | #:Probably because Track-tion vs Apex was kids vs a 40kg spinner and the producers didn't want it to be over in one hit, so they allowed the wedge to give the kids a chance of letting the fight last longer than that single...hit....... Oh wait... [[User:Jimlaad43|<font color="black">J</font><font color="gold">im<font color="black">laa</font><font color="gold">d4</font></font><font color="black">3</font>]]([[User talk:Jimlaad43|talk]]) 11:38, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
||
|- |
|- |
||
− | |'''Winner''': |
+ | |'''Winner''': Carbide (4-9) |
|} |
|} |
||
Line 267: | Line 269: | ||
#OOTAed. <span style="font-family: Courier">[[User:Adster1005|<font color="#191970">Adster</font>]][[User talk:Adster1005|<font color="#FF0000">1005</font>]]</span> 07:57, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
#OOTAed. <span style="font-family: Courier">[[User:Adster1005|<font color="#191970">Adster</font>]][[User talk:Adster1005|<font color="#FF0000">1005</font>]]</span> 07:57, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
||
#I feel like Hypno-Disc's defeat at the last hurdle before the Grand Final is a good time to pay tribute to the best-performing classic series bots from the last two Ragnabots. In Ragnabot 2, our top four preboot machines were Atomic (4th), Typhoon 2 (6th), S3 (7th), X-Terminator (8th), and the 9th placers (Anarchy, Tornado, Raging Reality & Tsunami). This time, we see Typhoon 2 perform best and someone out of X-Terminator and Hypno-Disc take second and third, followed by the 9th placers (Spawn Again, Wheely Big Cheese, Manta, Rosie the Riveter II). Only two robots shared between each! Big shout-outs to Cedric Slammer for getting 17th place in both of the last two Ragnabots, and to all of the heroic 17ths like Texas Tornado, Overkill GTI, GBH 2 and Corkscrew Two. Now we just have to see whether Hypno-Disc can edge out X-Terminator! RAPID meanwhile, gets a guaranteed Top 3 finish, almost unnoticed - can they go one better? <span style="font-family:Pirulen; font-size:10pt">[[User:ToastUltimatum|<font color="maroon">'''T'''</font><font color="ff8c00">'''OAS'''</font>]][[User talk:ToastUltimatum|<font color="maroon">'''T'''</font>]]</span> 10:08, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
#I feel like Hypno-Disc's defeat at the last hurdle before the Grand Final is a good time to pay tribute to the best-performing classic series bots from the last two Ragnabots. In Ragnabot 2, our top four preboot machines were Atomic (4th), Typhoon 2 (6th), S3 (7th), X-Terminator (8th), and the 9th placers (Anarchy, Tornado, Raging Reality & Tsunami). This time, we see Typhoon 2 perform best and someone out of X-Terminator and Hypno-Disc take second and third, followed by the 9th placers (Spawn Again, Wheely Big Cheese, Manta, Rosie the Riveter II). Only two robots shared between each! Big shout-outs to Cedric Slammer for getting 17th place in both of the last two Ragnabots, and to all of the heroic 17ths like Texas Tornado, Overkill GTI, GBH 2 and Corkscrew Two. Now we just have to see whether Hypno-Disc can edge out X-Terminator! RAPID meanwhile, gets a guaranteed Top 3 finish, almost unnoticed - can they go one better? <span style="font-family:Pirulen; font-size:10pt">[[User:ToastUltimatum|<font color="maroon">'''T'''</font><font color="ff8c00">'''OAS'''</font>]][[User talk:ToastUltimatum|<font color="maroon">'''T'''</font>]]</span> 10:08, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
||
+ | #Cheers lads, though it has to be said, RAPID was very lucky to draw Hypno-Disc here. But in keeping with how well robots like Spawn Again gave Hypno-Disc trouble, a reboot flipper of RAPID's power should have no issues here. [[User:SFCJack|SFCJack]] ([[User talk:SFCJack|talk]]) 10:35, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
||
− | |||
+ | #Anything Spawn Again and Dantomkia can do, Rapid can do better. [[User:VulcansHowl|<font color="green">'''Vulcans'''</font>]][[User talk:VulcansHowl|<font color="#5d8aa8">'''Howl'''</font>]] 11:18, January 28, 2020 (UTC) |
||
|- |
|- |
||
− | |'''Winner''': |
+ | |'''Winner''': Rapid (0-13) |
|} |
|} |
Latest revision as of 23:54, 29 January 2020
Forums: Index > Ragnabot 3 > Ragnabot 3 Semi-Final 2
Round of 16[]
Rapid vs Rosie the Riveter 2[]
Rapid | Rosie the Riveter 2 |
---|---|
Road to the Semi-Finals
|
Road to the Semi-Finals
|
Votes for Rapid
|
Votes for Rosie the Riveter 2 |
Winner: Rapid (13-0) |
Big Nipper vs Behemoth[]
Big Nipper | Behemoth |
---|---|
Road to the Semi-Finals
|
Road to the Semi-Finals
|
Votes for Big Nipper
|
Votes for Behemoth
|
Winner: Big Nipper (11-2) |
Magnetar vs Carbide[]
Magnetar | Carbide |
---|---|
Road to the Semi-Finals
|
Road to the Semi-Finals
|
Votes for Magnetar
|
Votes for Carbide
|
Winner: Carbide (6-7) |
Wheely Big Cheese vs Hypno-Disc[]
Wheely Big Cheese | Hypno-Disc |
---|---|
Road to the Semi-Finals
|
Road to the Semi-Finals
|
Votes for Wheely Big Cheese
|
Votes for Hypno-Disc
|
Winner: Hypno-Disc (0-14) |
Round of 8[]
Big Nipper vs Carbide[]
Big Nipper | Carbide |
---|---|
Road to the Semi-Finals
|
Road to the Semi-Finals
|
Votes for Big Nipper
|
Votes for Carbide
|
Winner: Carbide (4-9) |
Hypno-Disc vs Rapid[]
Hypno-Disc | Rapid |
---|---|
Road to the Semi-Finals
|
Road to the Semi-Finals
|
Votes for Hypno-Disc | Votes for Rapid
|
Winner: Rapid (0-13) |